TmBmbadl wrote:

Not all, I bought Rush's Permanent Waves 7 or 8 years ago and I still enjoy it as much as I did back then and I'll probably keep playing it for a long time. The fact that you haven't listened to an album worth more than a couple of spins doesn't mean they don't exist.

View Profile | Leave TmBmbadl a shout

JimKnopf- wrote:

all albums do, thats no argument

View Profile | Leave JimKnopf- a shout

TmBmbadl wrote:

It gets boring after a while

View Profile | Leave TmBmbadl a shout

KnightsofRound wrote:

Ugh, Amaranth has the most listeners, yet it is one of the worst songs on this album. Figures.

View Profile | Leave KnightsofRound a shout

Tokyo_Moon wrote:

Great album :D

View Profile | Leave Tokyo_Moon a shout

WT-The-Fan wrote:

Noo, how dare you!! : D .. It's the best nightwish had made, but not in the whole world? :D Best album in the world : Skillet - Comatose

View Profile | Leave WT-The-Fan a shout

misooo13 wrote:

Dark Passion Play is the best album in this world <3

View Profile | Leave misooo13 a shout

if-then-else wrote:

If you guys got the Audio DVD of it, with a little work you can have two versions of this album (one with only the orchestra, one with only the band). The orchestral version of Sahara is simply incredible.

View Profile | Leave if-then-else a shout

JesuBlut wrote:

I partly like this album. The Poet and the Pendulum is one of the best songs I've ever heard and I also like that Marco sings much more as in the time with Tarja. He's great. :)

View Profile | Leave JesuBlut a shout

nti wrote:

I like this album.

View Profile | Leave nti a shout

peaceandvictory wrote:

Eine Der besten Bands die ich kenne, werde auch weiterhin ihre Musik hören

View Profile | Leave peaceandvictory a shout

ProgresiveLanD wrote:

This is the most experimental and fresh album of nightwish, almost all songs are good, this is my ranking: 1-The Poet And The Pendulum 2-Sahara 3-Meadows of Heaven 4-Master Passion Greed 5-Eva 6-The Islander 7-Last of the Wilds 8-7Days To The Wolves 9-For the Heart I Once Had 10-Cadence of Her Last Breath 11-Whoever Brings the Night 12-Amaranth 13-Bye Bye Beautiful

View Profile | Leave ProgresiveLanD a shout

Rozen-rot wrote:

I don't have a problem with people saying they don't like this album, or Anette. But I find it ludicrous to suggest that a change in singers changes the genre of the band! What about the other 80% of the band? Dark Passion Play is no more Pop then Once. Both follow a similar direction.

View Profile | Leave Rozen-rot a shout

Gowienczyk wrote:

True that.

View Profile | Leave Gowienczyk a shout

Nisstyre56 wrote:

People who say it's "crap" or their "worst album" are fucking dipshits. ;)

View Profile | Leave Nisstyre56 a shout

Larvius wrote:

Great album, though it would be awesome if they would had replaced Whoever brings the Night with While your Lips are still red :f

View Profile | Leave Larvius a shout

Gowienczyk wrote:

Melodic and "pop" vocals as people describe them are better for the genre, anyway.

View Profile | Leave Gowienczyk a shout

Rozen-rot wrote:

Alas the vocals do not make the band. Having a weak 'poppy' voice is not enough to counteract the actual musical instruments, the drums and guitars are far to heavy for rock, and their mere presence would rule out the pop label. So, yup, still metal, no matter how hard you complain that you don't like the new album, that doesn't actually affect the genre. Also Nightwish were always on the softer less extreme side of metal, so no change there. Further 'pop' voices can and do work in several metal bands. This is metal, have no doubt sourgrapes.

View Profile | Leave Rozen-rot a shout