Pretty quickly after I joined Last.fm last September, I wrote a journal where I listed my favorite 10 albums of all time. I recently looked back at it and almost felt embarrassed. My tastes have changed an incredible amount since September, so I decided I would go through my library and pick out a new top 10. Interestingly, only one album from the previous list made it into my new top 10.
EDIT (7/31/08): As always, this is already very out of date. I'll make a new one in September.
10. Exile on Main Street (The Rolling Stones)
Exile on Main Street is, without a doubt in my mind, the Rolling Stones' magnum opus. It takes everything the Stones were known and matures it. There is a layer of grit and experimentation spread across these two discs, and there is no better example of this then the lead song "Rocks Off", which often at times sounds like something is wrong, or someone is making a mistake as they play. Songs like "Torn and Frayed" are lyrically quite bleak.
One reason the album has such a bleaker edge than their other albums is because of its production. This isn't slick by any means. For examples, the vocals often get blended into the mix, making it almost impossible to understand what is being said. Despite this sounding like a negative quality, it does nothing but add to the odd mood this album creates.
Exile on Main Street is a tough first listen. It's a tough second listen too. But the more one plays it, the more it will grow on them.
9. Origin of Symmetry (Muse)
Muse hasn't really released a bad album. Showbiz isn't terribly great and Black Holes is a little poppy, but both Absolution and Origin of Symmetry are terrific. And while Absolution is also incredible, I had to give the #9 spot to Origin.
The simplest reason why Origin of Symmetry is Muse's best album is the first 6 songs, the first half of the album. Every single song of the first 6 are incredible. "New Born" is an incredible album opener, "Citizen Erased" is perhaps Muse's most prog song, perfectly proceeded by "Plug In Baby", Muse's most catchy song.
That's not to say the second half of the albums is bad, not by any means. But the first 6 songs of the album are basically Muse bliss, and is without a doubt the best work they have produced.
8. BE (Pain of Salvation)
BE is a very difficult album to get into. It's extremely pretentious in that it attempts to explain god and the origin of life. Despite Pain of Salvation being a progressive metal band there is very little metal in this album. In fact it, with songs like "Pluvius Aestivus", you could argue that it's more classical than metal.
It's hard to explain why this album is so great, but if one listens to it with a completely open mind, they might come way surprisingly pleased. Despite the overblown concept, the album hits very emotionally with songs such as "Vocari Dei", where fans recorded messages of a very personal nature, questioning the existence of god.
The only way to understand what BE sounds like is to actually listen to it. With elements as varied as opera, metal, classical and progressive the result is something hard to comprehend, but extremely rewarding to those who can.
7. Wish You Were Here (Pink Floyd)
Here is the one album of my previous top 10 that made it on this list, albeit with a lower rank. Wish You Were Here is still, in my mind, the greatest work the Pink Floyd produced. Many people did not believe that they would be able to top the incredible "Dark Side of the Moon", but how they were wrong.
Wish You Were Here is bookended with the amazing "Shine on You Crazy Diamond", possibly Pink Floyd's best song. In the middle lies "Welcome to the Machine", "Have a Cigar" and the radio favorite "Wish You Were Here". Every song, every minute of this albums is incredible and never lags. If you think you're a Pink Floyd fan but only listen to Dark Side and The Wall you have no idea what you're missing.
6. The Beatles (The Beatles)
Also known as "The White Album" by fans, this is my favorite Beatles album. It was made at a time when the band was beginning to fragment. Every member of the band had different ideas musically and wanted the band to go in different directions. Despite this conflict, they managed to create perhaps the most unified album of their latter days.
This album is two discs that showcases the best work the Beatles produced. "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" is perhaps the highlight of the album with an incredible solo by guest Eric Clapton. Also, ending the album is the song "Revolution 9", which arguably started American avant-garde music.
It's the Beatles, and it's the Beatles' best work. What else really needs to be said?
5. Bridge Across Forever (Transatlantic)
Transatlantic is incredibly underrated, and any prog fan needs their two studio albums. While their first album is also incredible, Bridge Across Forever somewhat matures their songwriting to produce 4 classic songs. The two highlights of the album are the 20+ minute epic "Duel with the Devil" and the 30+ minute song "Stranger in Your Soul". Both are simply amazing progressive compositions.
There isn't really much to say about this album except that it really is musical genius, and any fan of progressive music should be able to appreciate it.
4. The Downward Spiral (Nine Inch Nails)
This is, without a doubt, the most controversial entry in this journal. How does an industrial rock album fit in with a decidedly progressive top 10? At least allow me to explain.
Trent Reznor, to put it bluntly, is somewhat a musical genius. While he may be somewhat mainstream, works such as "Ghosts I-IV" and the amazingly angry "Broken" prove that he has his own artistic vision.
The Downward Spiral is really a refinement of the previously mentioned EP "Broken". Broken was really just a half hour or so of pure hate and anger. The Downward Spiral takes the angst of Broken and matures it into a full LP. One reason I love Spiral so much is because of it's concept. While it may go over many people's heads, Spiral is the chronicle a mans descent into madness, and being driven to suicide at the end of the album.
The Downward Spiral is 65 minutes of madness, hate and anger, and insanity, possibly the most disturbing album in my collection. Because of the pure emotion this album emanates, I feel it is completely deserving of the number 4 spot in this list.
3. Colors (Between the Buried and Me)
If you want a longer explanation of why I find this album so incredible you can look for my journal post "Album of 2007", which I gave to this album. Colors is one 64 minute song, exploring many different musical ideas and providing a breathtaking package. Every minute is incredible, every idea fitting in to the larger picture. "Sun of Nothing", "Ants of the Sky", "Prequel to the Sequel", and "White Walls" especially are simply amazing. Between the Buried and Me won't appeal to everyone, but to those who can tolerate it, Colors is an amazing piece of work.
2. Morningrise (Opeth)
Opeth has always been known for incorporating non-metal elements into their sogns, and Morningrise is the prime example of this.
Moringrise is by far the most progressive of the Opeth albums, featuring only 5 songs all over 10 minutes and one over 20. It showcases the most complex songwriting of their albums and creates an incredible album because of it. I would go as far to say that every musical idea is not elaborated on for more then 30 seconds or so before it moves on to something else.
This complexity might make it hard for some to get into, which is why Opeth simplified their sound some for their later works, but for those who can stomach the genius of Morningrise, they will be rewarded with a masterpiece.
1. Awake (Dream Theater)
When I first got all of Dream Theater's albums I wasn't impressed with Awake. I was drawn to Octavarium and Metropolis, Part 2. Over time I expanded my interest and also fell in love with their other works like Six Degrees and Images & Words. Awake was probably the last album of theirs that I really got into.
Awake is Dream Theater's darkest album. Sure Train of Thought is heavier but Awake is a much moodier album. One reason Awake is Dream Theater's greatest album is the constraint they show. There are numerous incredible solos on the album, and even 10 minute or longer songs, but they never go into "musical masturbation" like they do on their more recent albums. Every solo, every line, adds to the emotion and mood of the respective songs.
And perhaps the most genius part of the album, strangely, is the pacing. Every song is located at the spot on the album that gives it the maximum impact possible. 6:00 is a terrific opener with Portnoy's into drum lick, the "A Mind Beside Itself" epic is rightfully located as the centerpiece of the album, just when the mellowness of "The Silent Man" grows a little thin, the heaviest song of the album ("The Mirror") comes crunching in. Just when it feels that song should end, it segues perfectly into the equally grim "Lie".
Perhaps the most emotional song Dream Theater has ever written, "Space Dye-Vest" is both perfect as an album closer and as a farewell by Kevin Moore. It deals lyrically with one closing himself off from the world ("And I'll never be open again"). It's genius use of samples and melancholy piano work creates an incredible experience.
All of these elements together make Awake the best album I have ever listened too. It's progressive but not overblown. It's emotional without being corny. It's heavy but not without mellow moments. It's moody without being cheesy. It's a masterpiece you need to listen to.
Connections:
Exile on Main Street
Rocks Off
Torn and FrayedSticky FingersOrigin of SymmetryAbsolution
New Born
Citizen Erased
Plug In BabyBE
Pluvius Aestivus
Vocari DeiWish You Were HereHave a CigarWish You Were HereWelcome To MachineThe BeatlesWhile My Guitar Gently WeepsRevolution 9MusePain of SalvationThe BeatlesBridge Across ForeverTransatlanticDuel With the DevilStranger in Your SoulThe Downward SpiralNine Inch NailsBrokenGhosts I-IVColorsBetween the Buried and MeMorningriseOpethAwakeDream Theater
Space-Dye Vest