RockOutMahn wrote:

I totally agree with you, IamAshit (god I feel funny typing that haha). Certain tracks from Make Believe definetly has the most genuine emotion from Rivers since Pinkerton.

View Profile | Leave RockOutMahn a shout

tomcbh wrote:

awesome album.

View Profile | Leave tomcbh a shout

yugman wrote:

Beverly Hills is garbage.

View Profile | Leave yugman a shout

JDest wrote:

Fuck those who want more of the same, its a good album cept for beverly hills.

View Profile | Leave JDest a shout

IamAshit wrote:

This album gets A LOT of shit, but it's more of a Weezer record than Maladroit or Red. These songs are solid, and I believe there is genuine emotion in some of these songs, but the plastic, clean production strips most of it away.

View Profile | Leave IamAshit a shout

ThermadorianGry wrote:

I'm a die-hard Weezer fan, but this album made it pretty hard to be. While some songs were okay, I found most of them to be waaaaayyyyy over the top, and I think it goes without saying that it doesn't even compare to the Blue Album.

View Profile | Leave ThermadorianGry a shout

RockOutMahn wrote:

I can't agree with the post below any more. Perfect Situation, This is Such A Pity, Hold Me, The Other Way, Haunt You Everyday, and hell, even Peace are the best post 2000 Weezer songs. Not The Greatest Man That Ever Lived and The Angel And The One. Those songs are overrated in my opinion.

View Profile | Leave RockOutMahn a shout

conditionals wrote:

After Red, I'm actually pining for the less 'jokey' Weezer that was sometimes on display here. 'Perfect Situation' and 'This is Such a Pity' are among the best Weezer songs, IMO.

View Profile | Leave conditionals a shout

sputnik57 wrote:

Fuck it, I like it.

View Profile | Leave sputnik57 a shout

ehsteve14 wrote:

The fact that the Japanese version has a live version of Butterfly at the end baffles me... by placing Rivers' arguably most personal song ever at the end of the album, it just accentuates how impersonal and trite the songwriting is on Make Believe

View Profile | Leave ehsteve14 a shout

Bolshevized wrote:

Weezer fans love to follow the herd I think. They hated Pinkerton when it came out and now they say it's one of their best albums. Likewise, this, an album with plenty of solid songs, gets slagged off. It has a few clonkers, but it didn't disappoint me at all.

View Profile | Leave Bolshevized a shout

Omnium wrote:

Horrendous record. Beverly Hills managed to discredit the entire album all by itself. Red had better be more like Blue or it will disappoint so many fans.

View Profile | Leave Omnium a shout

odysseyandoracl wrote:

Some good songs, some that are laughably bad. Is it possible that an album can be mixed and not just either incredibly awesome best ever or worst piece of music ever recorded in the history of man? Also, this album has nothing to do with Pinkerton in any way, shape, or form.

View Profile | Leave odysseyandoracl a shout

drussellsdct wrote:

abortion of an album.

View Profile | Leave drussellsdct a shout

cjones99 wrote:

I like We are all on drugs cuz it's a fun song

View Profile | Leave cjones99 a shout

FUWWWAIIII wrote:

second pinkerton my ass

View Profile | Leave FUWWWAIIII a shout

mrsgreenwood88 wrote:

i thought this was their weakest album so far. i hope the new one is better.

View Profile | Leave mrsgreenwood88 a shout

Jimmert wrote:

stand out tracks are perfect situation, hold me, damage in your heart and haunt you every day... can't really get into the other tracks. tried. failed.

View Profile | Leave Jimmert a shout